Case study 01 · Independent MSc research → strategy
The
Trust
Factor
Influence gets attention. Expertise earns consideration.
Understanding what makes Generation Z trust influencers and consider purchasing their recommendations.
@creator
Sponsored · #ad
Illustrative graphic
Research-led strategy
Influencer marketing
Consumer behaviour
2026
What actually makes an influencer persuasive?
Popularity and visibility get creators seen — but they don't automatically make them credible. Brands spend on reach; audiences decide who to believe.
Research question
How do perceived trustworthiness, expertise and attractiveness relate to purchase intention among Generation Z consumers in the United Kingdom?
Rooted in Source Credibility Theory. Hover or tap a dimension.
256 voices. Three dimensions of credibility.
256
valid responses
18–29
UK residents
SPSS 29
IBM SPSS Statistics
Online
Microsoft Forms questionnaire
- Design
- Quantitative, deductive, cross-sectional
- Sampling
- Non-probability convenience sampling
- Analysis
- Reliability analysis, descriptive statistics, Pearson correlation, multiple linear regression
- Theory
- Source Credibility Theory
- 1
Research question
- 2
Survey design
- 3
Data collection
- 4
Data screening
- 5
Statistical analysis
- 6
Findings
Expertise came out on top.
β values are standardised coefficients, not percentages.
41.1%
Variance in reported purchase intention explained by the three credibility dimensions collectively.
- R²
- 0.411
- Adjusted R²
- 0.404
- F(3,252)
- 58.699
- p
- < .001
All three credibility dimensions were statistically significant positive predictors of purchase intention — all three hypotheses were supported.
Expertise had the strongest independent relationship with purchase intention when trustworthiness and attractiveness were considered alongside it. The model describes reported intention, not actual purchases, and does not establish causation.
What should brands take from this?
Strategic implications — not tested outcomesPrioritise relevant expertise
Brands should consider whether creators have credible knowledge and experience within the product category they are promoting.
Build trust through transparency
Honest communication, clear sponsorship disclosures and consistent recommendations can help maintain audience confidence.
Make audience appeal count
Personality, presentation and the relationship with an audience still matter when selecting creators.
Look beyond follower counts
Influencer selection should consider credibility and relevance alongside reach and engagement.
From insight to creative execution.
A portfolio exercise: how GLOW LAB, a fictional Gen Z skin-care brand, could apply the findings. Campaign idea: “Know Before You Glow” — lead with expertise, prove it with honest reviews, make it desirable with aspirational creators.
Three illustrative creator personas
Persona 01 · fictional
The Category Expert
A qualified skin-care formulator who explains ingredients.
Leads on: Expertise
Persona 02 · fictional
The Trusted Everyday Reviewer
A student who tests products honestly — including the ones that don't work.
Leads on: Trustworthiness
Persona 03 · fictional
The Aspirational Lifestyle Creator
A creator whose routines and aesthetic audiences aspire to.
Leads on: Attractiveness
Illustrative creator evaluation scorecard (1–5)
| Creator | Trust | Expertise | Appeal | Category fit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Category Expert | ■■■■■ | ■■■■■ | ■■■■■ | Assess per brief |
| Trusted Everyday Reviewer | ■■■■■ | ■■■■■ | ■■■■■ | Assess per brief |
| Aspirational Lifestyle Creator | ■■■■■ | ■■■■■ | ■■■■■ | Assess per brief |
Example scores for the fictional personas only. Weighting suggestion: expertise first, then trustworthiness and attractiveness, alongside reach and relevance.
Selection framework
- 1Relevance — does the creator genuinely belong in this category?
- 2Expertise — can they explain the product credibly?
- 3Trust — do they disclose, stay consistent and admit downsides?
- 4Appeal — will the audience want to keep watching?
- 5Then reach & engagement — as context, not the deciding factor.
Sample Instagram carousel concept
Myth: more steps = better skin
What the expert actually checks
Ingredient 101
Honest review: 4 weeks in
Know before you glow. #ad
Short-form video concept · 30s
- 0–3s Hook: “I formulate skin care. Here's what I'd never buy.”
- 3–20s Expert breaks down the label on camera.
- 20–27s Cut to everyday reviewer's honest result.
- 27–30s Clear #ad disclosure + “Know before you glow.”
Messaging & content direction
- → Explain, don't hype.
- → Show the downsides as well as the wins.
- → Disclose sponsorship upfront.
- → Keep personality — credibility shouldn't feel dull.
No performance metrics shown — this concept has not been executed.
What the data can and cannot tell us.
- —Convenience sampling — results describe this sample, not every UK Gen Z consumer.
- —Cross-sectional data — a single snapshot in time.
- —Self-reported purchase intention, not actual purchasing behaviour.
- —Participants evaluated different self-selected influencers, platforms and product categories.
- —Findings show statistical relationships, not proof of causation.
The best influencer for a brand isn't always the one with the biggest following.
The research suggests that perceived expertise, trustworthiness and attractiveness all matter when consumers evaluate influencer recommendations. For brands, that means creator selection needs to go beyond visibility and consider the credibility behind the content.
- Research and consumer insight
- Quantitative data analysis
- Influencer marketing strategy
- Creative campaign conceptualisation